CameraReview

Tamron SP AF 17-50mm F/2.8 XR Di II VC LD Aspherical IF B005 vs Tokina AT-X Pro AF SD 16-50mm F/2.8 IF DX — Which Is Better?

Tamron SP AF 17-50mm F/2.8 XR Di II VC LD Aspherical IF B005 versus Tokina AT-X Pro AF SD 16-50mm F/2.8 IF DX
Side by side43 specifications
69
WINNER
Tokina · f/2.8 · Canon EF mount Tokina AT-X Pro AF SD 16-50mm F/2.8 IF DX
65
SCORE
Tamron SP AF 17-50mm F/2.8 XR Di II VC LD Aspherical IF B005
Tokina AT-X Pro AF SD 16-50mm F/2.8 IF DX
General
Release Year 20092006
Production Status
ⓘ
Current status of lens manufacturing (e.g., in production, discontinued).
DiscontinuedDiscontinued
Version
ⓘ
The iteration or release number of a particular lens model.
IIN/A
Pro Branding
ⓘ
Specific branding codes used for professional-tier lenses.
SPAT-X
Lens Mount
ⓘ
The lens mount will tell you what type of lens range you can fit onto the camera body. Often the same camera company will have different lens ranges for different cameras.
Canon EFCanon EF
System
ⓘ
Indicates which camera system the lens is designed to attach to.
Canon EOSCanon EOS
Maximum Format
ⓘ
Largest sensor size compatible with the lens.
APS-CAPS-C
Physical85/10085/100
Lens Weight 570 g610 g
Lens Diameter
ⓘ
Width of the lens at its widest point
79.6 mm84 mm
Lens Length
ⓘ
How long the lens is from front to back.
94.5 mm97.4 mm
Front Filter Compatible
ⓘ
Some lenses are compatible with front filters, some are compatible with back filters and some are compatible with both. Front filters are usually more convenient to add and remove.
YesYes
Front Filter Size
ⓘ
Diameter of attachable filters.
72 mm77 mm
Optics77/10081/100
Focal Range
ⓘ
Shortest to longest focal length of the lens (zoom range start - end )
17–50 mm16–50 mm
Aperture Range
ⓘ
Largest aperture at the lens's shortest focal length to longest focal length (aperture range start - end)
2.82.8
Focal Length Angle of View 76.24297121133672°–29.87709839212881°79.63931466313332°–29.87709839212881°
Flange Focal Distance
ⓘ
Distance from lens mount to sensor.
44 mm44 mm
Diaphragm Type
ⓘ
Structure and design of the aperture
AutomaticAutomatic
Blades
ⓘ
Number of diaphragm blades in aperture
70209020
Zoom Lens
ⓘ
Zoom allows you to vary the focal length, change between long shots and close-ups
YesYes
Zoom Mechanism
ⓘ
System enabling zoom function
ManualManual
Zoom Ring
ⓘ
If zooming is adjusted using a zoom ring
YesYes
Zoom Type
ⓘ
The design or approach to zooming
RotaryRotary
Closest Focusing Distance
ⓘ
Minimum distance for a subject to be in focus.
29 cm0150030 cm01500
Maximum Magnification
ⓘ
Largest size a subject can be reproduced
0.21x0.2x
Autofocus Mode YesYes
Manual Mode YesYes
Manual Focusing Ring YesYes
Features41/10019/100
Weather Sealing
ⓘ
Weather sealing capabilities will give you more confidence when shooting in unfavourable conditions.
✗✗
Fluorine Coating
ⓘ
Coating to repel water and oil from lens elements.
✗✗
Built In Lens Hood ✗✗
Lens Hood Type PetalPetal
Zoom Lock
ⓘ
Zoom lock allows the zoom ring to be locked at the desired focal length
YesNo
Teleconverter
ⓘ
A teleconverter (extender) is an extra piece of equipment that fits between the lens and the camera body to enhance magnification
YesYes
Image Stabilization ✓✗
IS Efficiency
ⓘ
IS efficiency refers to the effectiveness of the image stabilization system in compensating for the blurring effects of camera shake, quantified by the number of stops of stabilization it provides.
4 stopsN/A
Construction54/10038/100
Elements
ⓘ
Lens elements refer to individual pieces of glass within the lens.
1915
Groups 1412
Aspherical Elements
ⓘ
The number of aspherical lens elements which can help correct aberrations such as spherical aberration.
11
Bi Aspherical Elements
ⓘ
Elements with two non-spherical surfaces
00
Low Dispersion
ⓘ
Elements that reduce chromatic aberration
10
Super Low Dispersion
ⓘ
Advanced elements further reducing chromatic aberration
00
CA Reduction
ⓘ
Built-in features to reduce chromatic aberration
00
Internal Focusing
ⓘ
Internal Focusing means that the lens does not change in size during focusing, and the front element does not rotate.
YesYes

Your comparison

Choose two to four lenses.